The Grip Primer: Same Chemistry, $27 Less
Milk Makeup's Hydro Grip invented the sticky-gel primer category at $38. e.l.f.'s Power Grip is $11 — and the ingredient lists explain why they perform alike: both are built on the same grip film-former. Where they differ, the cheaper one is arguably cleaner.
| The Name: Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer | The Alternative: e.l.f. Power Grip Primer + 4% Niacinamide | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $38 (1.5 oz — ~$25/oz) | $11 (0.8 oz — ~$13.75/oz) |
| You save | — | $27 (71%) per tube; about 45% less per ounce |
| Grip chemistry | PEG-240/HDI copolymer film-former — the ingredient that makes foundation stick | The same PEG-240/HDI copolymer film-former |
| Formula extras | Blue agave extract; niacinamide at an undeclared dose — and alcohol denat. as the 4th ingredient | Niacinamide declared at 4%, plus hyaluronate and vitamin E; no alcohol denat. |
| Owner signal | Alcohol base is the recurring sensitive-skin complaint (stinging, pilling over sunscreen) | Near-identical hold in head-to-head use; pills if over-applied |
Prices checked by hand on October 23, 2026 at Ulta and Sephora; prices move with sales — confirm before you buy.
Our verdict: the alternative wins. Same grip chemistry, a declared 4% niacinamide dose, no alcohol denat., and roughly 45% lower cost per ounce — Milk is coasting on being first. The honest catch: e.l.f.'s tube is barely half Milk's size (0.8 oz vs 1.5 oz), so heavy users finish it about twice as fast, and its thicker tack makes it easier to over-apply and pill.
Where the money goes
- The grip: both gels are silicone-free water bases built on the same film-former — that's why reviewers who've used both land in the same place: same tack after 30–60 seconds, same all-day hold.
- The alcohol: Milk's formula distinction is marketing-forward (blue agave), while its alcohol denat. — 4th on the ingredient list — is a real downside e.l.f. doesn't have, and the source of its sensitive-skin complaints.
- The tube math: the sticker gap (3.5×) overstates it. Per ounce it's ~$13.75 vs ~$25 — still a decisive e.l.f. win, just an honest one.
See the alternative at Ulta See the original at Sephora
Dopperly may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page, at no cost to you. Full disclosure. We are never paid to change a verdict.